Thompson Creek - Nissqually Valley News - Court rules JZ Knight had standing to oppose subdivisions
Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2011 7:16 pm
the Nissqually valley news:
LOCAL NEWS
Print | E-mail | Comment (No comments posted.) | Rate | Text Size
Court rules in Knight’s favor
0 0
Thompson Creek flows through Knight’s property, which is located near the proposed subdivisions. File photo/Nisqually Valley News
City, channeler disagree over significance
By Megan Hansen
Nisqually Valley News
Published: Friday, December 23, 2011 3:54 PM PST
Washington Supreme Court ruled Channeler JZ Knight had standing to oppose five area subdivisions, ending a four-year controversy.
The High Court reversed a Court of Appeals decision and upheld the Thurston County Superior Court ruling that said the city must prove it has enough water to support a development at Final Plat Approval and Building Permit Stage.
The court also ruled no party involved was awarded attorney’s fees or court costs.
“I am elated to know that the Supreme Court saw the potential harm to property owners who have legal rights to the aquifer that would serve these proposed developments,” Knight said in a prepared press release.
“This decision sends a clear message to municipalities who make land use decisions without due consideration of the consequences to people who will be adversely impacted, even when those people own property outside of their jurisdiction.”
Knight’s team sees the ruling as a landmark decision that addresses water and land use law in the state.
“I am very pleased that the court affirmed what JZ Knight has been saying since 2007 about the city’s failure to show water availability for proposed subdivisions,” said Keith Moxon, Knight’s attorney.
“The court not only agreed that Knight had the right to challenge the City of Yelm’s approval of these subdivisions, it agreed that the city failed to meet the water availability requirements of state law.”
“It’s a good day for citizens of the State of Washington when courts uphold the rights of private property owners to challenge unlawful land use decisions that endanger precious water resources.”
While the court ruled in favor of Knight, City of Yelm officials said it’s not much of a victory.
“While we are disappointed in the decision, we are relieved that the Supreme Court did not make any precedent-setting decisions related to how and when the appropriate provision for potable water supply be made,” Yelm Mayor Ron Harding said.
“Bottom line — this decision does nothing more than say that Knight had the right to file a lawsuit and because so, does not have to pay attorney fees.”
The Superior Court decision came down to “/or” in a hearing examiner’s preliminary approval of the subdivisions, which would bring more than 500 homes into the area.
Knight argued the development could harm her senior water rights and that the city should show proof of potable water at preliminary plat approval.
The hearing examiner said the city had to prove potable water at Final Plat Approval and/or building permit stage.
Yelm Community Development Director Grant Beck said the “/or” was included because some of the sites had binding site plans, but that the city regularly operates showing proof of water at both stages.
“The approvals were upheld with that change and the city didn’t have a problem with that,” said Yelm City Administrator Shelly Badger.
City of Yelm decided to join the developers involved with the case in appealing the decision because during the Superior Court case findings the city deemed “offensive and inaccurate” about its water rights were included in the decision.
The city kind of debated appealing the decision in Court of Appeals and going after attorney’s fees because “our mission was kind of done,” Beck said. “We knew it was a long shot.”
But the Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the city, finding Knight didn’t have standing to oppose the developments and awarded the city and developers reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs. That’s the decision the Supreme Court overruled.
In the end, the suit has cost the city more than $132,000.
“At the end of the day the subdivisions are still approved with language from 2009,” Badger said. “A lot of public time and resources have been spent and we’re in the same place as 2008.”
“The city’s original preliminary plat approval of the five subdivisions was upheld by Superior Court, Court of Appeals and Supreme Court. The city’s process of determining adequate water supply at the preliminary stage was deemed appropriate.
And last but certainly not least, the city will make another determination of water availability at final subdivision approval as it is required to do by state law.”
http://www.yelmonline.com/articles/2011 ... 190047.txt